A video that circulated on social media of young Saudi men, said to be from Al Qassim region, cooking a crocodile and then eating it at a gathering feast, sparked widespread controversy in the Kingdom.
The video shows a number of young men choosing a small crocodile among several others in what looks like their home backyard, and then slaughtering it, skinning it to prepare for cooking, and finally presenting it in a feast with two bowls of rice.
عشانا اليوم تمساح ??https://t.co/XRmdnrmcjx
— ⚡️⛈رعد القصيم⛈⚡️ (@nasser7115) January 20, 2020
#ملك_التوقعات pic.twitter.com/cHdrOSFyUu
Translation: “Our dinner tonight is crocodile.”
One of the attendees asks another person about the taste of crocodile meat, who expresses his love for it, claiming that it is similar to the taste of fish.
نبي شي بدال التمساح بالمندي وش ترشحون لنا
— ⚡️⛈رعد القصيم⛈⚡️ (@nasser7115) January 22, 2020
اهم شي يكون حلال
#قصمان_ياكلون_تمساح pic.twitter.com/yvtnzNPKSZ
Translation: “We want to try another type of meat other than crocodile that is Halal, what do you recommend?”
Reactions to the video were divided. While some people found the incident repelling, arguing that crocodile meat is disgusting and forbidden to eat in Islam, others defended the young men's feast by arguing that eating exotic animals such as lizards is very common in the kingdom.
#قصمان_ياكلون_تمساح
— مشعل الشيباني (@masheyl511) January 22, 2020
طيب وش المشكله حنى حتى الضب في داخل جحره نسحبه بكعرته لين نطلعه وناكله pic.twitter.com/V3jAh74PJx
Translation: “What’s the problem with crocodile meat? So what? We hunt lizards to eat and it’s totally normal.”
Other people complained that they won’t judge people for their diets, arguing that every culture’s cuisine varies, but that they simply find crocodiles to be disgusting animals and wouldn’t eat them themselves.
#قصمان_ياكلون_تمساح
— إبراهيم المنيف (@altamimi14) January 22, 2020
بصراحة منظر التمساح اصلاً يسد النفس، عاد كيف وهو مطبوخ، وكيف اتخيل نفسي آكله؟!?
الله يكرم النعمة، كله على بعضه ما ينقبل
> لكن، (الأطعمة عبارة عن ثقافات)، وطالما انه مسموح ومافي سبب للإنكار عليهم، فلا يسعنا أن نقول لهم إلا:
(بالهنا والعافية، الله يقبله)?
Translation: “To be honest, the appearance of crocodiles are enough to make me puke let alone eat it.. But people from different cultures eat different meats and to each their own. Islam said nothing about crocodile meat.”
Meanwhile, others suggested that these people are just doing it to be popular and get followers or YouTube subscribers.
للاسف الشهره والضهور الاعلامي على اشياء ماتتقبلها النفس البشريه وتعارض المعترف عليه بنظري اشوفها مرض نفسي بوقتنا الحالي وهالنوعيه وصلو للي يبونه على حساب بطونهم الي اتوقع والعلم عند الله محد قوا ياكل من ذا التمساح ?
— jac (@az7rb) January 22, 2020
Translation: “Unfortunately, fame and popularity makes people do unacceptable things. I think these people are mentally ill, nobody who is sane would eat a crocodile.”
مع أحترامي لكم لم تأكلوه ضحيتو بواحد فقط لمجرد الإعلان ونجحتم في ذلك
— خالد السلماني (@KALED_S_M) January 23, 2020
Translation: “With all due respect, you did this to promote yourself, and it worked.”
The major reaction to the video was from people debating the Islamic perspective of eating crocodile meat, and whether it is “Halal” or “Haram”.
يعتبر من الحيوانات البحرية والله اعلم و احل بن عثيمين ... مع العلم إني ضد أكله م اكل.. pic.twitter.com/p9sqfe5Vfm
— م. مستنير الشمري ?? (@M_Sll10) January 22, 2020
Translation: Tweet #1:“It has fangs so we can’t eat it.”
Tweet #2: “It’s technically seafood so we can’t say for sure. I’d still be against eating it though.”